# Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui v. State of U.P. & Anr

- **Citation:** (2023) 2 ILRA 1144
- **Court:** High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
- **Decided:** 2022-09-30
- **Case number:** Application U/S 482. No. 17101 of 2020
- **Bench:** Samit Gopal
- **Source:** https://unisonlegal.in/judgment/allahabad-high-court/zaki-ur-rahman-siddiqui-v-state-of-u-p-anr-49184
- **Pages:** 52

## Headnote

Law
-
Code
of
Criminal
Procedure, 1973 -Section 482-summoning
order under challenged- to quash multiple
criminal cases- different FIRs lodged-82
petitions filed against different case crime
numbers challenged to be quashed in a single
petition-allegations by different farmers- for
the applicant taking possession forcefully of 5
hectare land from them by former minister
and former C.O. (City) by forging records and
threatening them of false implication- and
taking them within the boundary wall of the
university-Court cannot delve into the defence
of accused-only prima facie case has to be
looked into-no case of interference is made
out.

All applications dismissed. (E-9)

List of Cases cited:

## Text

_Characters 0–39,995 of 102,750. This is a partial read: ask again with offset=39995 for what follows._

1144 INDIAN LAW REPORTS ALLAHABAD SERIES
490/2021 प्रस्तुि कर दिया दजसके अांगीकरण के
प्रश्न पर सुनवाई करिे हुए सत्र न्यायाधीश अलीगढ़ ने
मुख्य न्यादयक मदजस्टरेट के आिेश को अांिषविी
आिेश (Interlocutory Order) मानिे हुए िथा यह
दनष्कर्ष िेिे हुए दक प्रस्तादवि अदभयुि की दनगरानी
प्रस्तुि करने का अदधकार नहीां है, दनगरानी खाररज
कर दिया। सत्र न्यायाधीश ने इस िथ् का भी सांज्ञान
दलया गया दक न िो उनके दवरुद्ध कोई दवदधक
प्रदक्रया ही जारी की गयी है न ही मामले का सांज्ञान
ही दलया गया है।

14. इस स्तर पर यह दनष्कर्ष नहीां दिया जा
सकिा है दक सांज्ञेय सूचना के िथ् गलि हैं िथा
काउण्टर ब्लास्ट के रूप में यह असांज्ञेय सूचना िजष
करायी गयी है। दनदिि रूप में उभय पक्षोां में दववाि
एवां िुश्मनी है। दववाि या िुश्मनी िोधारी िलवार
होिी है, जो घटना काररि करने का कारण भी हो
सकिा है िथा गलि फांसायें जाने का कारण भी बन
सकिा है। परन्तु इस स्तर पर यह नहीां कहा जा
सकिा दक यह प्रश्नगि असांज्ञेय सूचना गलि रूप से
प्राथीगण को फांसाने के दलए ही िजष करायी गयी है।

15. दनगरानीकिाष की िरफ से यह िकष भी
प्रस्तुि दकया गया दक असांज्ञेय अपराध सांख्या गलि
दलखी गयी िथा धारा 155(2) िां०प्र०सां० के प्राथषना
पत्र में सरफराज के स्थान पर उसके भाई नादजम
द्वारा हस्ताक्षर दकया गया। जहाँ िक गलि अांज्ञेय
अपराध की सांख्या दलखने का प्रश्न है यह दलदपकीय
त्रुदट हो सकिी है। इस न्यायालय के मिानुसार जब
यह धारा 482 िां०प्र०सां० की यादचका ही सांधायष नहीां
है िथा प्राथीगण को अभी वाि कारण ही उत्पन्न नहीां
हुआ है, अिः इन िथ्ोां पर दवचार करने का प्रश्न
उत्पन्न नहीां होिा है।

16. उपरोि पररस्स्थदियोां में इस न्यायालय का
भी यह अदभमि है दक अधीनस्थ न्यायालयोां द्वारा पाररि
िोनोां आिेश िथ्िः एवां दवदधिः सही एवां वैध हैं िथा
धारा 482 िां०प्र०सां० के अांिगषि उि िोनोां आिेश
खस्ण्डि दकये जाने योग्य नहीां हैं। धारा 482 िां०प्र०सां०
दनम्नवि है-

17. इस सांदहिा में कुछ भी उच्च न्यायालय के
अांिदनषदहि शस्ियाां व्यावृदि इस सांदहिा की कोई बाि
उच्च न्यायालय को ऐसा आिेश िेने की अांिदनषदहि
शस्ियोां को सीदमि या प्रभावी करने वाली न समझी
जाएगी जैसा इस सांदहिा के अधीन ऐसे दकसी आिेश
को प्रभावी करने के दलए या दकसी न्यायालय की
कायषवाही का िुरुपयोग दनवाररि करने के दलए या
दकसी अन्य प्रकार से न्याय के उद्देश्योां की प्रास्प्त
सुदनदिि करने के दलए आवश्यक है।

18. इस न्यायालय के अनुसार प्राथीगण द्वारा
अनुदचि िौर पर ऐसे आिेशोां की धारा 482 िां०प्र०सां० के
अांिगषि चुनौिी दिया गया है, दजन्ें चुनौिी िेने का अभी
कोई वाि कारण उन्ें प्राप्त नहीां है। अिः यह यादचका
अपररपक्व होने के कारण खाररज दकये जाने योग्य है।

19. दनगरानीकिाष की िरफ से प्रभू चावला बनाम
राजस्थान राज्य और एक अन्य िण्ड अपील सां०
842/2016 एवां िण्ड अपील सां० 845-846/2016 में
उच्चिम न्यायालय द्वारा पाररि आिेश दिनाांक 5
दसिांबर 2016 को स्यां पर आधाररि दकया गया दजसके
िथ् प्रस्तुि मामले के िथ्ोां से पूणषिया दभन्न थे। अिः
इसमें दनधाषररि दवदध का दसद्धान्त प्राथीगण के के पक्ष में
प्रयुि नहीां होिा।

आदेि

20. यह यादचका उपरोिानुसार दनरस्त की
जािी है। इस दनणषय की एक प्रदि मुख्य न्यादयक
िण्डादधकारी अलीगढ़ को सूचनाथष एवां अनुपालनाथष
प्रेदर्ि की जाये।
----------
(2023) 2 ILRA 1144
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL SIDE
DATED: ALLAHABAD 30.09.2022

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE SAMIT GOPAL, J.

Application U/S 482. No. 17101 of 2020
And
Other Connected Cases

Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui ...Applicant
Versus
State of U.P. & Anr. ...Opposite Parties
2 All. Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui Vs. State of U.P. & Anr.
1145
Counsel for the Applicant:
Sri Sadaful Islam Jafri, Sri Khalid Mahmood,
Sri Nazrul Islam Jafri (Senior Adv.)

Counsel for the Opposite Parties:
G.A.

Criminal
Law
-
Code
of
Criminal
Procedure, 1973 -Section 482-summoning
order under challenged- to quash multiple
criminal cases- different FIRs lodged-82
petitions filed against different case crime
numbers challenged to be quashed in a single
petition-allegations by different farmers- for
the applicant taking possession forcefully of 5
hectare land from them by former minister
and former C.O. (City) by forging records and
threatening them of false implication- and
taking them within the boundary wall of the
university-Court cannot delve into the defence
of accused-only prima facie case has to be
looked into-no case of interference is made
out.

All applications dismissed. (E-9)

List of Cases cited:

1. R.P. Kapur Vs St. of Punjab: AIR 1960 SC 866
(Para-6)

2. St. of Har. & ors. Vs Ch. Bhajanlal & ors.:
(1992) AIR 604

3. T.T. Antony Vs St. of Kerala & ors.: 2001 SCC
OnLine SC 805

4. Upkar Singh Vs Ved Prakash : 2005 SCC
(Criminal) 211

5. Arnab Ranjan Goswami Vs U.O.I.: (2020) 14
SCC 12

6. Prem Chand Singh Vs St. of U.P.: 2020 SCC
OnLine SC 144

7. St. of M. P. Vs Sheetla Sahai & ors.: 2009 SCC
OnLine SC

8. Prabhu Chawla Vs St. of Raj. & anr. : 2016
SCC OnLine SC

9. Kishan Singh (Dead) through LRS Vs Gurpal
Singh & ors.: 2009 SCC OnLine SC 1451

10. Dhariwal Tobacco Products Ltd. & ors. Vs St.
of Maharastra & anr. : (2009) 2 Supreme Court
Cases 370

11. Vijay Kumar Ghai & ors. Vs St. of W. B. &
ors.: 2022 SCC

12. Issac Isanga Musumba & ors. Vs St. of Mah.
& ors.: (2014) 15 SCC 579

13. Tarak Dash Mukharjee & ors. Vs St. of U.P. &
ors- Criminal Appeal No. 1400 of 2022

14. Mitesh Kumar J. Sha Vs St. of Karnataka &
ors.: 2021 SCC Online SC

15. St. of Karn. Vs Muniswamy & ors. : 1977
Supreme Court Cases (Cri) 404

16. J. Anbazhagan Vs The Speaker, Tamil Nadu
Legislative Assembly & ors. :(2018) SCC OnLine
Mad 1235

17. Shashimani Mishra Vs St. of M.P. : I.L.R.
(2019) M.P. 1397

18. R.P. Kapur Vs St. of Pun.: AIR 1960 SC 866

19.
Madhavrao
Jiwaji
Rao
Scindia
Vs
Sambhajhirao Chandrojirao Angre : (1988) 1
SCC 692

20. St. of Har. & ors. Vs Bhajan Lal & ors.: 1992
Supp (1) SCC 335

21. Chilakamarthi Venkateswarlu & anr. Vs St. of
Andhra Pradesh & anr. (2020) 17 SCC 595,

22. T.T. Antony Vs St. of Ker. : (2001) 6 SCC 181

23. Babubhai Vs St. of Guj.: (2010) 12 SCC 254

24. Anju Chaudhary Vs St. of U.P. : (2013) 6
SCC 384

25. Amitbhai Anichandra Shah Vs C.B.I. : (2013)
6 SCC 348

26. S.K. Alagh Vs St. of U.P. : (2008) 5 SCC 661
1146 INDIAN LAW REPORTS ALLAHABAD SERIES
27. Aneeta Hada Vs Godfather Travels & Tours
Pvt. Ltd.: (2012) 5 SCC

28. Sharad Kumar Sanghi Vs Sangita Rane :
(2015) 12 SCC 781

29. GHCL Employees Stock Option Trust Vs
Kranti Sinha: (2013) 4 SCC 505,

30. Kranti Kumar Vs St. of U.P. : Crl. Misc.
Application U/S 482 No. 7050 of 2002

31. Kranti Kumar Vs St. of U.P.: Crl. Misc.
Application U/S 482 No. 7060 of 2002

32. Oanali Ismilji Sadikot Vs St. of Guj. : (2016)
SCC OnLine Guj 10055

33. Arnab Ranjan Goswami Vs U.O.I. : (2020)
14 SCC 51

34. Arnab Ranjan Goswami Vs U.O.I. : (2020)
14 SCC 12

35. Amish Devgan Vs U.O.I.: (2021) 3 SCC 306

36. Ketaki Chitale Vs St. of Mah.: Crim. Misc.
W.P. No. 1919 of 2022

37. Nikhil Shyamrao Bhamare Vs St. of Mah.,
Criminal Misc. Writ Petition No.1821 of 2022

38. Umesh Kumar Vs St. of Andhra Pradesh :
(2013) 10 SCC 591

39. Krishna Lal Chawla & ors. Vs St. of U.P. &
anr. : LL2021 SC 145

40. Mitesh Kumar J. Sha Vs St. of Karn. & ors.:
LL 2021 SC 592

41. (1) Babubhai Jamuna Bhai Patel Vs St. of
Guj.: (2010) 12 SCC 254

42. Barendra Kumar Ghosh Vs Emperor: AIR
1925 PC 1(C)

43. M/S Neharika Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. Vs St.
of Mah.: (2021) SCC OnLine SC 315

44. Jagmohan Singh Vs Vimlesh Kumar & ors.:
(2022) LiveLaw (SC) 546,

45. Ramveer Upadhyay & anr. Vs St. of U.P. &
anr.: (2022) LiveLaw (SC) 396;

46. Chilakamarthi Venkateswarlu & anr. Vs St. of
Andhra Pradesh & anr.: Criminal Appeal No.
1082 of 2019

47. Kaptan Singh Vs St. of U.P. & ors.: AIR 2021
SC 3931

48. St. of Odisha Vs Pratima Mohanty : (2021)
SCC OnLine SC 1222,

49. Priti Saraf & ors. Vs St. of NCT of Delhi &
ors.: AIR 2021 SC 1531,

50. Anil Vs St. of U.P. & anr.: Criminal Misc.
Application U/S 482 Cr.P.C. No. 6504 of 2021,
dated 30.6.2021

51. Wasiullah & anr. Vs St. of U.P. & ors.:
2021(1) All. LJ 42;

52. Pankaj Tyagi Vs St. of U.P. & anr. : 2022 SCC
OnLine All 163

53. Asha Ranjan Vs St. of Bihar & ors.: (2017) 4
SCC 397

54. Surender Kaushik & ors. Vs St. of U.P. &
ors.: (2013) 5 SCC 148;

55. Lalman & ors. Vs St. of U.P. & ors.: (2021)
ILR 2 All 167;

56. Beekki Verma Vs St. of U.P. & ors.: 2021 (5)
ADJ 351.

57. R.P. Kapur Vs St. of Pun. : AIR 1960 SC 866;

58. St. of Har. & ors. Vs Bhajan Lal & ors. : 1992
Supp (1) SCC 335;

59. St. of Bihar Vs P.P. Sharma : 1992 Supp (1)
SCC 222;

60. Trisuns Chemical Industry Vs Rajesh
Agarwal & ors. : (1999) 8 SCC 686;

61. M. Krishnan Vs Vijay Singh & anr. : (2001) 8
SCC 645; Zandu Pharmaceuticals Works Ltd. Vs
Mohammd Shariful Haque : (2005) 1 SCC 122;
2 All. Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui Vs. State of U.P. & Anr.
1147
62. M. N. Ojha Vs Alok Kumar Srivastava :
(2009) 9 SCC 682;

63. Joseph Salvaraj A. Vs St. of Guj. & ors. :
(2011) 7 SCC 59;

64. Arun Bhandari Vs St. of U. P. & ors. : (2013)
2 SCC 801;

65. Md. Allauddin Khan Vs St. of Bihar : (2019)
6 SCC 107;

66. Anand Kumar Mohatta & anr. Vs St. (NCT of
Delhi), Department of Home & anr. : (2019) 11
SCC 706

67. Rajeev Kourav Vs Balasaheb & ors. : (2020)
3 SCC 317;

68. Nallapareddy Sridhar Reddy Vs The St. of
Andhra Pradesh : (2020) 12 SCC 467

69. Priti Saraf & anr. Vs St. of NCT of Delhi &
anr. : Criminal Appeal No(s). 296 of 2021

70. Daxaben Vs St. of Guj. : 2022 SCC Online
SC 936

(Delivered by Hon'ble Samit Gopal, J.)

1. These 82 petitions filed under
Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 ("Cr.P.C.") are connected
together as they have common issues
within themselves which are interlinked.
They all have been filed after the
investigation in the respective matters has
concluded, charge-sheets have been filed
and the accused persons have been
summoned to face trial. The stage of filing
of the petitions is after cognizance on the
charge-sheets have been taken by the
concerned court and the accused persons
have been summoned. The challenge in all
the petitions is thus at the stage of
summoning.

2. At this stage it would be important
to give the details of the First Information
Reports in a tabular form case crime
number wise. In all there are 27 case crime
numbers covering the full bunch of cases.
The details are as follows (Table-A) :-

Table-A

Sl.No.
Date
of
lodgin
g
of
FIR
Case
Crime
No.,
sectio
ns,
Police
Statio
n,
Distri
ct
First
infor
mant
Accu
sed
name
d in
FIR
Iden
tific
atio
n of
land
1
12.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0224
of
2019,
u/ss.
342,
447,
506,
384
I.P.C.,
P.S.
Azee
mnaga
r,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur.
Man
oj
Kum
ar,
Reve
nue
Inspe
ctor
(i)
Moha
mma
d
Azam
Khan,
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan
Gata
No.
123
9,
Area
0.11
4
Hect
.,
Gata
No.
123
2,
Area
0.12
6
hect.
,
Gata
No.
141
5
Area
0.08
9
hect.
,
Gata
No.
125
3/1,
Area
0.08
9
hect.
,
1148 INDIAN LAW REPORTS ALLAHABAD SERIES
Gata
No.
131
9
Kha,
Area
1.29
4
hect.
,
2
13.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0226/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
447,
384,
504,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Yase
en
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
Khet
No.
123
2,
Area
3
13.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0227/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Band
ey
Ali
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
Gata
No.
123
2
4
14.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0228/
Moh
d.
Ahm
ad
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Gata
No.
123
2
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
5
15.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0232/
2019,
U/S.
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Kalla
n
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
Bhu
mi
No.
123
0
6
16.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0235/
2019,
U/S.
342,
447,
384,
504,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Hane
ef
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
Bhu
mi
No.
123
2
2 All. Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui Vs. State of U.P. & Anr.
1149
7
16.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0236/
2019,
U/S.3
23,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Shar
eef
Ahm
ad
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
Bhu
mi
No.
123
0
8
16.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0237/
2019,
U/S.3
23,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Moh
d.
Must
akee
m
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
Bhu
mi
No.
141
5
9
16.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0238/
2019,
U/S.3
23,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Matl
oob
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
Bhu
mi
No.
131
9Kha
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
10
16.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0239/
2019,
U/S.
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Nasir
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
Bhu
mi
No.
123
2
11
16.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0240/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Nazi
m
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
Bhu
mi
No.
125
3/1
12
16.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0241/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
447,
384,
506
Nabb
u
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
Bhu
mi
No.
125
3/1
1150 INDIAN LAW REPORTS ALLAHABAD SERIES
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
City.
13
16.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0242/
2019,
U/S.
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Zum
ma
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
Bhu
mi
No.
123
0
14
18.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0248/
2019,
U/S.
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Moh
d.
Hasa
n
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
Bhu
mi
No.
131
9
Kha
15
18.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0249/
2019,
Rafiq
ue
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Bhu
mi
No.
125
3/1
U/S.
323,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
16
19.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0250/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
384,4
47,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Moh
d.
Hane
ef
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
Bhu
mi
No.
141
5
17
19.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0251/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
384,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Bhull
an
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Bhu
mi
No.
141
5
2 All. Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui Vs. State of U.P. & Anr.
1151
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
18
19.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0252/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
384,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Moh
d.
Yase
en
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
Bhu
mi
No.
141
5
19
19.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0253/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
384,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Naa
mey
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
Bhu
mi
No.
123
0
20
19.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0254/
2019,
Abra
r
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Bhu
mi
No.
123
0
U/S.
323,
342,
384,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
21
19.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0255/
2019,
U/S.
323,
506,
447,3
84,
342
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Naza
kat
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
Bhu
mi
No.
123
0
22
19.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0256/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
384,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Ame
er
Alam
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Bhu
mi
No.
131
9
Kha
1152 INDIAN LAW REPORTS ALLAHABAD SERIES
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
23
19.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0257/
2019,
U/S.
342,
384,
447,
504,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Resh
ma
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
Bhu
mi
No.
123
2
24
20.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0260/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Moh
d.
Alim
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
Bhu
mi
No.
131
9
Kha
25
20.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0261/
2019,
Zakir
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Bhu
mi
No.
123
2
U/S.
323,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
26
20.7.2
019
Case
Crime
No.
0262/
2019,
U/S.
323,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Noor
Alam
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O.
Bhu
mi
No.
131
9
Kha
27
3.8.20
19
Case
Crime
No.
0295/
2019,
U/S.
506,
389,
447,
342,
323
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azee
m
Nagar,
Asrar
(i)
Azam
Khan
(ii)
Aley
Hasa
n
Khan,
Form
er
C.O.,
City.
(iii)
Kush
alvee
r
Gata
No.
123
0
2 All. Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui Vs. State of U.P. & Anr.
1153
Distric
t
Ramp
ur
Singh
,
Form
er
S.H.
O

3. Five Petitions being Criminal Misc.
Application U/S 482 Nos.9832 of 2021
(Aley Hasan Khan vs. State of U.P. and 31
others), 16848 of 2020 (Mohd. Fasih Zaidi
vs. State of U.P. and 27 others), 1149 of
2021 (Mustaq Ahmad Siddqui vs. State of
U.P. and 27 others), 10254 of 2021 (Adeeb
Azam vs. State of U.P. and 27 others) and
9822 of 2021 (Nikhat Aflakh vs. State of
U.P. and 27 others) have been filed with
the prayers for quashing of multiple charge
sheets and proceedings of cases which are
as follows (Table-B) :-

Table-B

l. No.
Criminal
Misc.
Application
U/S
482
Nos.
Prayers:-
1
9832
of
2021, Aley
Hasan Khan
vs. State of
U.P. and 31
others
For quashing and stay the
proceedings of :-

1. Sessions Case No. 311of
2020, Case Crime No. 224
of 2019, u/s 120B, 342,
386, 389, 420, 447, 506
I.P.C., P.S.- Azeem Nagar,
District Rampur.
2. Sessions Case No. 315 of
2020, Case Crime No. 226
of 2019, u/s 120B, 323,342,
386, 389, 420, 447, 504,
506 I.P.C., P.S.- Azeem
Nagar, District Rampur.
3. Sessions Case No. 328 of
2020, Case Crime No. 227
of 2019, u/s 120B, 323,342,
386, 389, 420, 447, 506
I.P.C., P.S.- Azeem Nagar,
District Rampur.
4. Sessions Case No. 335 of
2020, Case Crime No. 228
of 2019, u/s 120B, 323,342,
386, 389, 420, 447, 504,
506 I.P.C., P.S.- Azeem
Nagar, District Rampur.
5. Sessions Case No. 312 of
2020, Case Crime No. 232
of 2019, u/s 120B, 323,342,
386, 389, 420, 447, 506
I.P.C., P.S.- Azeem Nagar,
District Rampur.
6. Sessions Case No. 320 of
2020, Case Crime No. 235
of 2019, u/s 120B, 323,342,
386, 389, 420, 447, 504,
506 I.P.C., P.S.- Azeem
Nagar, District Rampur.
7. Sessions Case No. 336 of
2020, Case Crime No. 236
of 2019, u/s 120B, 323,342,
386, 389, 420, 447, 506
I.P.C., P.S.- Azeem Nagar,
District Rampur.
8. Sessions Case No. 324 of
2020, Case Crime No. 237
of 2019, u/s 120B, 323,342,
386, 389, 420, 447, 506
I.P.C., P.S.- Azeem Nagar,
District Rampur.
9. Sessions Case No. 337 of
2020, Case Crime No. 238
of 2019, u/s 120B, 323,342,
386, 389, 420, 447, 506
I.P.C., P.S.- Azeem Nagar,
District Rampur.
10. Sessions Case No. 310
of 2020, Case Crime No.
239 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
11.Sessions Case No. 332
of 2020, Case Crime No.
240 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
12. Sessions Case No. 322
of 2020, Case Crime No.
241 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
1154 INDIAN LAW REPORTS ALLAHABAD SERIES
13.Sessions Case No. 316
of 2020, Case Crime No.
242 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
14. Sessions Case No. 334
of 2020, Case Crime No.
248 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
15. Sessions Case No. 331
of 2020, Case Crime No.
249 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
16. Sessions Case No. 338
of 2020, Case Crime No.
250 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
17. Sessions Case No. 321
of 2020, Case Crime No.
251 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
18. Sessions Case No. 325
of 2020, Case Crime No.
252 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
19. Sessions Case No. 326
of 2020, Case Crime No.
253 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
20. Sessions Case No. 333
of 2020, Case Crime No.
254 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
21. Sessions Case No. 329
of 2020, Case Crime No.
255 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
22. Sessions Case No. 318
of 2020, Case Crime No.
256 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
23. Sessions Case No. 330
of 2020, Case Crime No.
257 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447, 504, 506 I.P.C., P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
24. Sessions Case No. 314
of 2020, Case Crime No.
260 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
25. Sessions Case No. 319
of 2020, Case Crime No.
261 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
26. Sessions Case No. 327
of 2020, Case Crime No.
262 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
27. Sessions Case No. 317
of 2020, Case Crime No.
295 of 2019, u/s 120B,
323,342, 386, 389, 420,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.-
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur.
2
16848
of
2020,
Mohd.
Fasih Zaidi
vs. State of
To quash supplementary
charge sheet as well as
summoning orders dated
16.9.2020 and the entire
proceedings of :-
2 All. Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui Vs. State of U.P. & Anr.
1155
U.P. and 27
others

1. Special Case No. 122 of
2020, Case Crime No. 224
of 2019.
2. Special Case No. 924 of
2020, Case Crime No. 226
of 2019.
3. Special Case No. 936 of
2020, Case Crime No. 227
of 2019.
4. Special Case No. 123 of
2020, Case Crime No. 228
of 2019.
5. Special Case No. 935 of
2020, Case Crime No. 232
of 2019.
6. Special Case No. 118 of
2020, Case Crime No. 235
of 2019.
7. Special Case No. 127 of
2020, Case Crime No. 236
of 2019.
8. Special Case No. 927 of
2020, Case Crime No. 237
of 2019.
9. Special Case No. 126 of
2020, Case Crime No. 238
of 2019.
10. Special Case No. 125 of
2020, Case Crime No. 239
of 2019.
11. Special Case No. 124 of
2020, Case Crime No. 240
of 2019.
12. Special Case No. 115 of
2020, Case Crime No. 241
of 2019.
13.Special Case No. 121 of
2020, Case Crime No. 242
of 2019.
14. Special Case No. 117 of
2020, Case Crime No. 248
of 2019.
15. Special Case No. 933 of
2020, Case Crime No. 249
of 2019.
16. Special Case No. 929 of
2020, Case Crime No. 250
of 2019.
17. Special Case No. 921 of
2020, Case Crime No. 251
of 2019.
18. Special Case No. 120 of
2020, Case Crime No. 252
of 2019.
19. Special Case No. 128 of
2020, Case Crime No. 253
of 2019.
20. Special Case No. 926 of
2020, Case Crime No. 254
of 2019.
21. Special Case No. 930 of
2020, Case Crime No. 255
of 2019.
22. Special Case No. 925 of
2020, Case Crime No. 256
of 2019.
23. Special Case No. 934 of
2020, Case Crime No. 257
of 2019.
24. Special Case No. 928 of
2020, Case Crime No. 260
of 2019.
25. Special Case No. 931 of
2020, Case Crime No. 261
of 2019.
26. Special Case No. 932 of
2020, Case Crime No. 262
of 2019.
27. Special Case No. 937 of
2020, Case Crime No. 295
of 2019.
3
1149
of
2021,
Mustaq
Ahmad
Siddiqui vs.
State
of
U.P. and 27
others
To quash supplementary
charge sheet as well as
summoning orders dated
16.9.2020 and the entire
proceedings of :-

1. Special Case No. 122 of
2020, Case Crime No. 224
of 2019.
2. Special Case No. 924 of
2020, Case Crime No. 226
of 2019.
3. Special Case No. 936 of
2020, Case Crime No. 227
of 2019.
4. Special Case No. 123 of
2020, Case Crime No. 228
of 2019.
5. Special Case No. 935 of
2020, Case Crime No. 232
of 2019.
6. Special Case No. 118 of
2020, Case Crime No. 235
of 2019.
7. Special Case No. 127 of
2020, Case Crime No. 236
of 2019.
8. Special Case No. 927 of
1156 INDIAN LAW REPORTS ALLAHABAD SERIES
2020, Case Crime No. 237
of 2019.
9. Special Case No. 126 of
2020, Case Crime No. 238
of 2019.
10. Special Case No. 125 of
2020, Case Crime No. 239
of 2019.
11. Special Case No. 124 of
2020, Case Crime No. 240
of 2019.
12. Special Case No. 115 of
2020, Case Crime No. 241
of 2019.
13.Special Case No. 121 of
2020, Case Crime No. 242
of 2019.
14. Special Case No. 117 of
2020, Case Crime No. 248
of 2019.
15. Special Case No. 933 of
2020, Case Crime No. 249
of 2019.
16. Special Case No. 929 of
2020, Case Crime No. 250
of 2019.
17. Special Case No. 921 of
2020, Case Crime No. 251
of 2019.
18. Special Case No. 120 of
2020, Case Crime No. 252
of 2019.
19. Special Case No. 128 of
2020, Case Crime No. 253
of 2019.
20. Special Case No. 926 of
2020, Case Crime No. 254
of 2019.
21. Special Case No. 930 of
2020, Case Crime No. 255
of 2019.
22. Special Case No. 925 of
2020, Case Crime No. 256
of 2019.
23. Special Case No. 934 of
2020, Case Crime No. 257
of 2019.
24. Special Case No. 928 of
2020, Case Crime No. 260
of 2019.
25. Special Case No. 931 of
2020, Case Crime No. 261
of 2019.
26. Special Case No. 932 of
2020, Case Crime No. 262
of 2019.
27. Special Case No. 937 of
2020, Case Crime No. 295
of 2019.
4
10254
of
2021,
Adeeb
Azam
vs.
State
of
U.P. and 27
others
To quash the supplementary
charge sheet dated 3.9.2020
as
well
as
summoning
orders dated 16.9.2020 as
well as entire proceedings
of :-

1. Special Case No. 122 of
2020, Case Crime No. 224
of 2019.
2. Special Case No. 104 of
2020, Case Crime No. 226
of 2019.
3. Special Case No. 114 of
2020, Case Crime No. 227
of 2019.
4. Special Case No. 123 of
2020, Case Crime No. 228
of 2019.
5. Special Case No. 103 of
2020, Case Crime No. 232
of 2019.
6. Special Case No. 118 of
2020, Case Crime No. 235
of 2019.
7. Special Case No. 127 of
2020, Case Crime No. 236
of 2019.
8. Special Case No. 112 of
2020, Case Crime No. 237
of 2019.
9. Special Case No. 126 of
2020, Case Crime No. 238
of 2019.
10. Special Case No. 125 of
2020, Case Crime No. 239
of 2019.
11. Special Case No. 124 of
2020, Case Crime No. 240
of 2019.
12.Special Case No. 115 of
2020, Case Crime No. 241
of 2019.
13. Special Case No. 121 of
2020, Case Crime No. 242
of 2019.
14. Special Case No. 117 of
2020, Case Crime No. 248
of 2019.
15. Special Case No. 106 of
2019, Case Crime No. 249
2 All. Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui Vs. State of U.P. & Anr.
1157
of 2019.
16. Special Case No. 108 of
2019, Case Crime No. 250
of 2019.
17. Special Case No. 107 of
2019 Case Crime No. 251
of 2019.
18. Special Case No. 120 of
2020, Case Crime No. 252
of 2019.
19. Special Case No. 128 of
2020, Case Crime No. 253
of 2019.
20. Special Case No. 102 of
2020, Case Crime No. 254
of 2019.
21. Special Case No. 110 of
2019, Case Crime No. 255
of 2019.
22. Special Case No. 105 of
2019, Case Crime No. 256
of 2019.
23. Special Case No. 125 of
2020, Case Crime No. 257
of 2019.
24. Special Case No. 113 of
2020, Case Crime No. 260
of 2019.
25. Special Case No. 109 of
2019, Case Crime No. 261
of 2019.
26. Special Case No. 111 of
2019, Case Crime No. 262
of 2019.
27. Special Case No. 129 of
2020, Case Crime No. 295
of 2019.
28. Special Case No. 134 of
2020, Case Crime No. 46 of
2019.
29. Special Case No. 135 of
2020, Case Crime No. 53 of
2019.
All cases are under Sections
447, 420, 120B I.P.C.
5
9822
of
2021,
Nikhat
Aflakh
vs.
State
of
U.P. and 27
others
To quash the supplementary
charge
sheet
dated
3.9.2020,
summoning
orders dated 16.9.2020 and
the entire proceedings of :-

1. Special Case No. 122 of
2020, Case Crime No. 224
of 2019.
2. Special Case No. 104 of
2020, Case Crime No. 226
of 2019.
3. Special Case No. 114 of
2020, Case Crime No. 227
of 2019.
4. Special Case No. 123 of
2020, Case Crime No. 228
of 2019.
5. Special Case No. 103 of
2020, Case Crime No. 232
of 2019.
6. Special Case No. 118 of
2020, Case Crime No. 235
of 2019.
7. Special Case No. 127 of
2020, Case Crime No. 236
of 2019.
8. Special Case No. 112 of
2020, Case Crime No. 237
of 2019.
9. Special Case No. 126 of
2020, Case Crime No. 238
of 2019.
10. Special Case No. 125 of
2020, Case Crime No. 239
of 2019.
11. Special Case No. 124 of
2020, Case Crime No. 240
of 2019.
12.Special Case No. 115 of
2020, Case Crime No. 241
of 2019.
13. Special Case No. 121 of
2020, Case Crime No. 242
of 2019.
14. Special Case No. 117 of
2020, Case Crime No. 248
of 2019.
15. Special Case No. 106 of
2019, Case Crime No. 249
of 2019.
16. Special Case No. 108 of
2019, Case Crime No. 250
of 2019.
17. Special Case No. 107 of
2019 Case Crime No. 251
of 2019.
18. Special Case No. 120 of
2020, Case Crime No. 252
of 2019.
19. Special Case No. 128 of
2020, Case Crime No. 253
of 2019.
20. Special Case No. 102 of
2020, Case Crime No. 254
1158 INDIAN LAW REPORTS ALLAHABAD SERIES
of 2019.
21. Special Case No. 110 of
2019, Case Crime No. 255
of 2019.
22. Special Case No. 105 of
2019, Case Crime No. 256
of 2019.
23. Special Case No. 125 of
2020, Case Crime No. 257
of 2019.
24. Special Case No. 113 of
2020, Case Crime No. 260
of 2019.
25. Special Case No. 109 of
2019, Case Crime No. 261
of 2019.
26. Special Case No. 111 of
2019, Case Crime No. 262
of 2019.
27. Special Case No. 129 of
2020, Case Crime No. 295
of 2019.
28. Special Case No. 134 of
2020, Case Crime No. 46 of
2019.
29. Special Case No. 135 of
2020, Case Crime No. 53 of
2019.
All cases are under Sections
447, 420, 120B I.P.C.

4. In so far as the applications being
Criminal Misc. Application U/S 482 Nos.
9832 of 2021 (Aley Hasan Khan vs. State of
U.P. and 31 others), 16848 of 2020 (Mohd.
Fasih Zaidi vs. State of U.P. and 27 others),
1149 of 2021 (Mustaq Ahmad Siddqui vs.
State of U.P. and 27 others), 10254 of 2021
(Adeeb Azam vs. State of U.P. and 27
others) and 9822 of 2021 (Nikhat Aflakh vs.
State of U.P. and 27 others) in Table-B,
shows that they have been filed with the
prayer to quash multiple criminal cases.

During the course of arguments an
option was given to the respective counsels
to consider the same and file separate
petitions for different case crime numbers,
but learned counsels pressed to argue the
matters.

5. In view of the same and as stated in
Table-B, it is evident that different case
crime numbers have been prayed for
quashing in a single petition of which the
first informants are different and the land in
dispute are different and as such the said
applications u/s 482 Cr.P.C. are dismissed
on the said count only.

6. The applicants of the said cases
shall have liberty to take up appropriate
remedy as advised.

7. The prosecution case in brief as per
the first information report of Case Crime
No. 224 of 2019 is as follows:-

The First Information Report was
lodged on 12.9.2019 by Manoj Kumar,
Revenue Inspector, Area Khaud, Tehsil
Sadar, Rampur, under Sections 384, 506,
447, 342 I.P.C., Police Station Azeem
Nagar, District Rampur against former
minister Mohd. Azam Khan and Aley
Hasan Khan is that Mohammad Ali,
Vandey Ali and Yaseen sons of Dhoomi,
have given a complaint in which after
inquiry it transpired that in village
Seegankhera,
Tehsil
Sadar,
District
Rampur, Gata No. 1239 area 0.114 hectare
entered in the name of Abrar Husain, Asrar
Husain sons of Abdul, Zumma, Namey Ali,
Nazakat sons of Mohammad Raza and
Abdul Rahman son of Wali Mohammad,
Lallan, Sharif Ahmad, Jeemal Ahmad sons
of Jhunda residents of Village Majra
Aliaganj, Gata No. 1232 area 0.126 hectare
entered in the name of Shayada wife of
Ahmad Navi, Ahmad Navi son of Mulla
Bahadur,
Sharif
Mohammad,
Ahmad,
Ahmad Ali, Bandey Ali, Riyazul Navi,
Naseer, Zakir sons of Mohammad Navi and
Smt. Reshma wife of Zakir Ali and
Maulana Mohammad Ali Jauhar Trust,
Gata No. 1415 area 0.089 hectare entered
2 All. Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui Vs. State of U.P. & Anr.
1159
in the name of Bhullan son of Abdul
Hakim, Mohammad Haneef, Mohammad
Yaseen,
Mohammad
Mustkeem,
Mohammad Naim sons of Ibrahim, Abdul
Waheed, Rahees Ahmad, Zareef Ahmad
sons of Abdul Zafar@ Gafoor, Zakir,
Naseer, Aarif, Aasif, Imran sons of Ahmad
Ashak, Anandi wife of Ahmad Ashak,
Rashid, Sajid, Danish, Monish sons of
Mohammad Ahmad, Smt. Halam Begum
wife of Mohammad Ahmad residents of
Majra Aliaganj and Maulana Mohammad
Ali Jauhar Trust, Gata No. 1253/1 area
0.089 hectare entered in the name of
Nazim, Nabbu, Mohammad Rafik sons of
Mohammad Yaseen, Smt. Begum wife of
Mohammad Yaseen, Mohammad Bilal,
Mohammad Hilal, Mohammad Munav,
Mohammad Umar sons of Mohammad
Salim,
Shakeela
Begum
wife
of
Mohammad Salim residents of Majra
Aliaganj, Gata No. 1319Kha area 1.294
hectare entered in the name of Mohammad
Aleem, Noor Alam, Amir Alam sons of
Abdul Husain, Mumtaz Begum wife of
Abdul Husain, Mohammad Hasan son of
Ahmad, Matloob son of Chhote, Shahjahan
wife of Chhote residents of Majra Aliaganj
are
recorded
as
''Sankramniya
Bhoomidhars' in the revenue records. The
respective farmers have given applications
with regards to the said land along with
affidavits on the basis of which their
statements were recorded in which the
farmers stated that former minister Azam
Khan and former C.O. (City) Aley Hasan
Khan were forcing them to execute sale
deeds in favour of the University and
threatened them that they would be
implicated in false cases of charas and
smack and they were illegally detained for
many days in lock up. They did not execute
the sale deeds in favour of the University in
spite of it, but former minister Azam Khan
and former C.O. (City) Aley Hasan Khan
forcibly took possession of their lands and
included it in the campus of the University.
Whenever they used to ask for their
property they used to get life threats and
used to chase them away. In the inquiry it
transpired that Gata Nos. 1230, 1232, 1415
are
within
the
walls
of
Maulana
Mohammad Ali Jauhar University whereas
Gata Nos. 1253/1 and 1319Kha are outside
the boundary wall. The land of farmers
mentioned in their applications have been
forcibly taken into possession by former
minister Azam Khan and former C.O.
(City) Aley Hasan Khan by threatening
them and stating of falsely implicating
them in false cases. It is further stated that
before it, former minister Azam Khan had
illegally taken 5.000 hectare land of river
which was also included in the campus of
the University within its boundary wall of
which a First Information Report has
already been lodged. From the above facts
it is clear that they have forcibly taken into
possession private and Government land by
forging records. It is prayed that looking to
the facts as stated above a First Information
Report be lodged against Mohammad
Azam Khan, Chancellor, and Aley Hasan
Khan, Chief Security Officer, Mohammad
Ali Jauhar University and appropriate
action be taken.

Further
a
First
Information
Report was lodged as Case Crime No. 226
of 2019, under Sections 323, 342, 447, 384,
504, 506 I.P.C., Police Station Azeem
Nagar, District Rampur by Yaseen son of
Dhoomi, against former minister Azam
Khan and former C.O. (City) Aley Hasan
Khan on 13.7.2019 alleging therein that he
is a resident of village Seegankhera Majra
Aliaganj. He is recorded as a co-holder in
land no. 1232 in village Seegankhera. On
the said land agricultural work is done by
him from which he nurtures his family. At
the time of construction of Mohammad Ali
1160 INDIAN LAW REPORTS ALLAHABAD SERIES
Jauhar University former minister Azam
Khan and former C.O. (City) Aley Hasan
Khan pressurized him to give his land to
them, assaulted him and detained him in a
lock up and further threatened him that in
the event he does not give the land he
would be implicated in cases of charas and
afeem and would be arrested. Even torture
was given to the ladies in his family and
children. He did not execute the sale deed
in favour of the University but his land was
included in the land of the University
within its boundary wall. He prays that a
report be lodged against former minister
Azam Khan and former C.O. (City) Aley
Hasan Khan. Justice be done.

The
other
First
Information
Reports being 25 in number are by different
informants with regards to their different
land of which numbers are stated there, the
details of which have already been stated in
Table-A.

8. The court concerned on receipt of
charge sheet took cognizance upon the
same and summoned the applicants and
other persons named therein in the
respective cases to face trial. The details of
the
order
taking
cognizance
and
summoning are as follows (Table-C) :-

Table-C

Sl.
No
.
Criminal
Misc.
Applicati
on
U/S
482 Nos.
Case
Crime
No.,
Section
s,
Police
Station,
District
Charge
Sheet No.,
sections,
accused
named
therein
Date
of
order
taking
cogniz
ance
and
summ
oning
1
17101/20
22
Case
Crime
No. 241
of 2019,
u/ss.
323,
Charge
Sheet No.
65A/2020,
dated
3.9.2020,
U/S 420,
16.9.2
020
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur
.
447, 120B
I.P.C.
i.Naseer
Ahmad
Khan,
ii.
Dr.
Tanzeen
Fatma,
iii. Modh.
Abdulla
Azam
Khan,
iv. Adeeb
Azam
Khan,
v. Sushri
Nikhat
Aflak,
vi. Salim
Kasim,
vii.
Mustak
Ahmad
Siddiqui,
viii.
Zakiurrah
man
Siddiqui
ix. Mohd.
Fasih
Zaidi
2
17097/20
20
Case
Crime
No.237
of 2019,
u/ss.
323,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur
.
Charge
Sheet No.
79A/2020,
dated
3.9.2020,
U/S 420,
447, 120B
I.P.C.
i.Naseer
Ahmad
Khan,
ii.
Dr.
Tanzeen
Fatma,
iii. Modh.
Abdulla
Azam
Khan,
iv. Adeeb
Azam
Khan,
v. Sushri
Nikhat
Aflak,
16.9.2
020
2 All. Zaki Ur Rahman Siddiqui Vs. State of U.P. & Anr.
1161
vi. Salim
Kasim,
vii.
Mustak
Ahmad
Siddiqui,
viii.
Zakiurrah
man
Siddiqui
ix. Mohd.
Fasih
Zaidi
3
17099/20
20
Case
Crime
No.224
of 2019,
u/ss.
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur
.
Charge
Sheet No.
84A/2020,
dated
3.9.2020,
U/S 420,
447, 120B
I.P.C.
i.Naseer
Ahmad
Khan,
ii.
Dr.
Tanzeen
Fatma,
iii. Modh.
Abdulla
Azam
Khan,
iv. Adeeb
Azam
Khan,
v. Sushri
Nikhat
Aflak,
vi. Salim
Kasim,
vii.
Mustak
Ahmad
Siddiqui,
viii.
Zakiurrah
man
Siddiqui
ix. Mohd.
Fasih
Zaidi
16.9.2
020
4
17100/20
20
Case
Crime
No.253
of 2019,
u/ss.
Charge
Sheet No.
286A/201
9,
dated
3.9.2020,
16.9.2
020
323,
342,
384,
447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur
.
U/S 420,
447, 120B
I.P.C.
i.Naseer
Ahmad
Khan,
ii.
Dr.
Tanzeen
Fatma,
iii.Modh.
Abdulla
Azam
Khan,
iv. Adeeb
Azam
Khan,
v. Sushri
Nikhat
Aflak,
vi. Salim
Kasim,
vii.Mustak
Ahmad
Siddiqui,
viii.
Zakiurrah
man
Siddiqui
ix. Mohd.
Fasih
Zaidi
5
17102/20
20
Case
Crime
No.255
of 2019,
u/ss.
323,
342,384
,447,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur
.
Charge
Sheet No.
288A/201
9,
dated
3.9.2020,
U/S 420,
447, 120B
I.P.C.
i.Naseer
Ahmad
Khan,
ii.
Dr.
Tanzeen
Fatma,
iii. Modh.
Abdulla
Azam
Khan,
iv. Adeeb
Azam
Khan,
v. Sushri
Nikhat
Aflak,
16.9.2
020
1162 INDIAN LAW REPORTS ALLAHABAD SERIES
vi. Salim
Kasim,
vii.
Mustak
Ahmad
Siddiqui,
viii.
Zakiurrah
man
Siddiqui
ix. Mohd.
Fasih
Zaidi
6
17103/20
20
Case
Crime
No.255
of 2019,
u/ss.
323,
506,
447,384
,342
I.P.C.,
P.S.
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur
.
Charge
Sheet No.
288A/201
9,
dated
3.9.2020,
U/S 420,
447, 120B
I.P.C.
i.Naseer
Ahmad
Khan,
ii.
Dr.
Tanzeen
Fatma,
iii. Modh.
Abdulla
Azam
Khan,
iv. Adeeb
Azam
Khan,
v. Sushri
Nikhat
Aflak,
vi. Salim
Kasim,
vii.
Mustak
Ahmad
Siddiqui,
viii.
Zakiurrah
man
Siddiqui
ix. Mohd.
Fasih
Zaidi
16.9.2
020
7
17127/20
20
Case
Crime
No. 241
of 2019,
u/ss.
Charge
Sheet No.
65A/2020,
dated
3.9.2020,
16.9.2
020
323,
342,
447,
384,
506
I.P.C.,
P.S.
Azeem
Nagar,
District
Rampur
.
U/S 420,
447, 120B
I.P.C.
i.Naseer
Ahmad
Khan,
ii.
Dr.
Tanzeen
Fatma,
iii. Modh.
Abdulla
Azam
Khan,
iv. Adeeb
Azam
Khan,
v. Sushri
Nikhat
Aflak,
vi.